Lunch & Dinner

My Way Tavern Holly Springs Lunch & Dinner Menu

The Best Food Around.

Order Online from My Way Tavern Holly Springs Now.

Order Online

With MobileBytes

Fried Banana Peppers

$9
Golden fried banana pepper rings, served with ranch

Pretzel Bites

$13
Lightly salted, served with beer cheese & honey Dijon

THE Buffalo Dip

$14
Creamy, spicy, shredded chicken dip with a hint of blue cheese served with tortilla chips

Brussels

$14
Flash fried brussel sprouts topped with bacon, blue cheese crumbles & drizzled with balsamic glaze

*Ahi Tuna

$18
Encrusted with lime pepper over wasabi cucumber dressing

Fried Onion Straws

$7
Finely sliced onion rings fried to golden perfection, served with ranch

Cajun Fried Potato Chips

$9
Thinly sliced, dusted with Cajun spice served with ranch

Tavern Nachos

$14
Smothered with spicy ground beef & beer cheese, topped with black beans, pico de gallo, jalapeños, lime crema & cilantro

Buffalo Shrimp

$13
Lightly breaded, fried & tossed in your choice of wing sauce

Wings (1lb)

$14
We have the following sauces / rubs:
  • Medium
  • Hot
  • Raspberry Chipotle
  • Spicy Asian
  • Spicy Garlic
  • My Way
  • Carolina Gold
  • Dry Rub Jerk
  • Spicy Dry Rub with Honey
  • Pineapple Reaper XX Hot (+$1)
  • El Jefé XXX Hot (+$1)

Try our new wing flavors:
GARLIC PARM & SPICY TERRIYAKI

Our soups are always scratch-made, because we know you’d prefer it that way.

French Onion

$8

House Chili

$8

Soup Du Jour

$8

Loaded

$11
Bacon, Cheese, Sour Cream & Butter

Broccoli Cheese

$11

Buffalo Chicken

$11

Chili, Cheese & Jalapeno

$11

Tavern

$11

Mixed greens, tomato, onion, cheese, bacon & croutons

  • Add Chicken +$6
  • Add Shrimp +$8
  • Add Beef Tenderloin +$9
  • Add Salmon +$12

Caesar

$10

Romaine lettuce, croutons & parmesan cheese
(Pictured with salmon)

  • Add Chicken +$6
  • Add Shrimp +$8
  • Add Beef Tenderloin +$9
  • Add Salmon +$12

Hawaiian

$17
Mixed greens, sweet marinated chicken, grilled pineapple, tomato, onion, bacon & feta cheese

The Rachel

$15
A tavern salad, topped with raspberry chipotle chicken tenders

BLT Wedge

$14
Blue cheese dressing, tomato, bacon & fried onion straws, drizzled with balsamic glaze

My Way Cobb

$19
Mixed greens, crispy fried chicken, tomato, onion, blue cheese crumbles, bacon, avocado & hard-boiled egg

*La Taberna Steak Salad

$20

Mixed greens, Cajun tenderloin, avocado, tortilla strips, black beans, cotija cheese & pico de gallo served with chipotle dressing

  • Substitute our homemade spicy black bean burger

Classic Mac

$12
Better than your grandma’s

Seafood Mac

$19
A creamy crab blend topped with shrimp

Chili Mac

$14
Made with our scratch made chili

Taco Mac

$14
Spicy ground beef, pico de gallo, black beans & tortilla chips

Spinach Mac

$14
Creamed spinach & bacon bits

Baby Back Mac

$16
Our baby back ribs and chives

Buffalo Mac

$14
Made with our creamy, spicy, shredded chicken dip with a hint of blue cheese

Baby Back Ribs

$24
Served with slaw & tavern fries

Porterhouse Pork Chop

$22
12oz bone-in chop topped with habanero bacon jam & roasted apples, served with mashed potatoes & garlic green beans

Fish & Chips

$18
Beer battered haddock served with slaw & tavern fries

*Rib Eye

$28

12oz cut topped with garlic-herb compound butter, served with baked potato & salad

  • Top it with a creamy crab blend and grilled shrimp - $8

Grilled Salmon

$24
Served with serrano-cilantro cream sauce, rice pilaf & garlic green beans

Chicken Fried Chicken

$18
Breaded chicken breast, served with country pepper gravy, mashed potatoes & garlic green beans

My Way Cajun Chicken

$15

Sautéed in a light Cajun cream sauce over linguini

  • Substitute shrimp - $3

Chicken Tenders

$16

Freshly cut, NEVER frozen, served with tavern fries & honey Dijon

  • Buffalo Style +$1
  • El Hefe XXHot & Pineapple Reaper +$2
  • Make It a Double Order - $30

*Add Guacamole for $3

Tacos Del Rié

$17
Three soft tacos stuffed with beef tenderloin, lettuce, pico de gallo, black beans, cheese & Sriracha aioli dressing

Baja Tacos

$15
Three soft tacos stuffed with fried haddock, lettuce, pico de gallo, black beans, cheese & chipotle dressing

Short Rib Tacos

$18
Three soft tacos stuffed with braised short ribs, cilantro, red onion, cotija cheese & serrano-cilantro cream sauce

Burgers

*Burger

$11

Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle spear & tavern fries

  • Substitute chicken +$1
  • Substitute spicy black bean burger

My Way Tavern Style Burgers

Barnyard Burger

$19
Baby back ribs, sunny side up egg, bacon & cheddar

Bacon Jam Burger

$17
Habanero bacon jam, jalapenos & pimento cheese

Sriracha Burger

$17
Sriracha aioli, pepper jack, sunny side up egg, fried banana peppers & bacon

Guacamole Burger

$17
Guacamole, grilled pineapple, ham & onion straws

Thanks… but I’d rather make it my way!

Build Your Own Burger

$12
~substitute Grilled Chicken Breast $14~substitute homemade Spicy Black Bean Burger $12
  • $0.80 Toppings
  • Grilled Onion
  • Jalapeños
  • Banana Peppers
  • Fried Onion Straws
  • Cajun Seasoning
  • BBQ
  • Grilled Pineapple
  • $1.00 Toppings
  • American Cheese
  • Swiss Cheese
  • Pimento Cheese
  • Cheddar Cheese
  • Provolone Cheese
  • Muenster Cheese
  • Pepper Jack Cheese
  • Blue Cheese Crumbles
  • Cotija Cheese
  • Feta Cheese
  • Coleslaw
  • Chili
  • Chimi-Churi Mayo
  • Sriracha Aioli
  • Horsey Sauce
  • Honey-Chipotle
  • Fried Egg
  • $3.00 Toppings
  • Bacon
  • Beer Cheese
  • Guacamole
  • Avocado
  • Habanero Bacon Jam

Hotdogs

Nathan's Hot Dog

$6
Served with fries...make it a Double Dog $8

Beer Bratwurst

$10
Sauerkraut & spicy mustard served with tavern fries...make it a Double Brat $16

Can't Decide?

$15

Bratwurst & Nathan's Hot Dog served with tavern fries

Regional Dogs

Carolina Dog

$9
Chili, slaw, onion & mustard

Upstate Dog

$9
Onion, sauerkraut, chili, & mustard

Game 6 Dog

$9
Grilled onion, sauerkraut & mustard

Chicago Dog

$10
Pickled sport peppers, diced tomato, relish, onion, celery salt, mustard & pickle spear

Mariner Dog

$10
Cream cheese, grilled onion, jalapeños & sriracha aioli

Tucson Dog

$10
Bacon slices, pico de gallo, mustard & BBQ

Fried Potato Chips

$5

Tavern Fries

$5

Pasta Salad

$4

Side Salad

$7

Garlic Green Beans

$6

Steamed Broccoli

$6

Brussels

$6

Onion Straws

$5

Rice Pilaf

$4

Baked Potato

$6

Mashed Potatoes

$6

Cheerwine Float

$8

Brownie Sundae

$11

Seasonal Cheesecake

$14

Caramel Apple Toffee Cake a la Mode

$14

*Denotes items that are served raw or undercooked and contain (or may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.